Step 1: Choose a light, natural eyeshadow color for a base, and sweep it across the lid and up to the brow bone (labeled, "underbrow," on diagram). I like using my Body Shop Eye Color Matte in #29.
Step 2: Now sweep a medium dark color from the upper lid, and into the crease. I like using Body Shop Eye Color in #44. It is a greenish, gold, shimmery color. This compliments my light blue/green eyes, and is still a medium dark color.
Step 3 (Optional): On the outer part of the lid, apply a darker color as a contour. This should almost be in this shape: <. It looks like the letter, "V," turned sideways. The color I suggest is Body Shop Eye Color in #16. (I walked into the Body Shop one day wearing the 2 colors shown above, and one of the workers added this dark, silvery color as a contour. I loved it, and ultimately bought the color.)